Electrical

iPhone 4CF

iphone4cf

Year: 2010

Title: iPhone 4CF

Type: website (www.apple-cf.com) , press release, and direct action

Authors: The Yes Men & students from the Parsons New School for Design via Yes Lab.

Availability: no longer available on original www.apple-cf.com website (shut down), but available on http://apple-cf.com.yeslab.org/ and on Flickr (slideshow embedded below)

Page reference: Parkin, J. (2011) iPhone 4cf. followthethings.com (www.followthethings.com/iphone4cf.shtml last accessed <insert date here>)

Original

iPhone4cf

Descriptions

On Nov. 16 [2010], the same day that Apple released the Beatles on iTunes, the Yes Men … launched a website (www.apple-cf.com) purporting a new iPhone4CF (Source: Chansanchai 2010 np link).

Two iPhones on a home screen showing images on their displays: Left: A dark skinned boy wearing a necklace of weapons carrying cartridges to the head. Right: Many dark-skinned hands smeared with coloured nail polish, it looks funny. In addition, the sentence: iPhone 4 CF. Better Phone. Better World. That's what she looks like, the better world at Apple on www.apple-cf.com. Gone are the days when iPhones consisted of politically incorrect raw materials and thus subsidized wars. Because now there is that iPhone 4CF ... An upgrade to the classic iPhone, which promises a conflict-free mobile phone. So beautiful could be the world if the homepage of Apple would be [like this]. But she is not (Source: Aust 2010 np).

‘CF’ stands for conflict-free, which ‘Apple’ promised its new phone would be. The new phone bested the old version by making sure its minerals weren't sourced from conflict-ridden regions like the Democratic Republic of Congo, where battles over mining rights have fueled countless atrocities and massacres. Apple's iPhone4-CF received a splashy product launch in the streets of New York, in front of the company's flagship Midtown Manhattan store (Source: YesLab 2010 np link).

Design-wise, the [iPhone CF] site was a dead-ringer for the main Apple site ... but by the time you got to the part where it called for the citizen's arrest of mining executives, you had to realize something was amiss ... The visually pitch-perfect site had all the hallmarks of the Yes Men (Source: Gilson 2010 np link).

The Conflict Free iPhone site mimics Apple’s web presence precisely, the layout and style are indistinguishable from a site Apple might produce. The text claims that the ‘new iPhone CF guarantees to all its customers the same high quality phone as the original iPhone 4 with the added bonus of taking you one step closer to a world without conflict.’ And further reports that Apple has decided to ensure the minerals used in the production of their devices are not sourced from mines in Africa ‘under the control of rebel groups further fuelling a conflict that has killed more than 5,000,000 civilians’ (Source: Oman-Reagan 2010 np link).

On November 16th, 2010, the website went live and an on-site intervention was staged where the YesLab, assisted by the Yes Men network, infiltrated the Apple store at 59th Street and Columbus Circle in New York City and posed as Apple employees, handing out vouchers to passerby's for the ‘iPhone 4CF’ to highlight the lack of knowledge most individuals have about conflict minerals and the war in the DRC, and as an amends, to allow them to trade their old phone in for a new ‘conflict free’ device (Source: Max 2016 np link).

If you own an iPhone 4, you can get it upgraded for free in our store in 767 Fifth Avenue, New York (Source: Yes Men 2010 np link).

[The iPhone 4CF] flyers were ... both advertisements and vouchers to act as the catalyst for the action ... filled with information and directions about how to receive an iPhone 4CF for free at the 5th Avenue Apple store. ... Consumers could take the voucher to the Apple store at [New York's] 5th Avenue where they could upgrade their current iPhone, that was not conflict free, for one that was. They relied on the fact that by imitating in appearance both Apple’s printed matter (by using its logo and font) and employees’ attire, they could convince people that the product actually did exist. And so they dressed up in printed Apple employee shirts that they had made, spread out around Midtown with their mission, and got to business (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.10-11 link).

The Yes Men supporters and customers who thought the ad was real went to the store and demanded a free upgrade to an iPhone 4 Conflict Free (Source: Musavuli in Musavuli & Bonanno nd np link).

People actually brought [the vouchers] into the store in Columbus Circle, and many Apple employees were surprised that Apple would create such a thoughtful product for the market (Source: Maxmgard 2015 np link).

The experience in the store was intriguing: Apple had informed its employees about the action, but it was impossible for the sellers to find out who the real customers were and who The Yes Men supporters were (Source: Musavuli in Musavuli & Bonanno nd np link).

Eventually, as members of the group started to go in and out of the Apple store, carrying the press releases with them and setting them down in the store, Apple itself responded for real. Those that went into the store were followed and asked to leave, and employees as well as supervisors began to make it known that whatever was going on was not making them especially pleased (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.10-11 link).

… they were already greeted by police officers when they arrived there (Source: Musavuli in Musavuli & Bonanno nd np link).

The police, having acknowledged the presence of more than a few people poised to do something, had set up an area for them to carry-out a ‘protest’ (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.11 link).

At [Apple’s] behest, the NYPD showed up en masse and attempted to barricade the students into a holding pen (Source: YesLab 2010 np link).

[There], the students staged a (fake) impromptu sidewalk press conference as fictional corporate liaisons, and brought together all the elements of their action in one final improvisation (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.10-11 link).

[Among other things, they] called for the arrest of John Paulson, founder of a New York-based hedge fund that heavily invests in the sort of Congo mining that fuels conflict.  (The NYPD did not respond with as much vigor to that request) (Source: YesLab 2010 np link).

Within hours Apple had applied its legal muscle and shut down the website (Source: iphoneproj2011 2011 np link).

Apple ... fired off a hostile e-mail to... [www.apple-cf.com's] service provider, and got the spot-on Apple.com imitation shut down (Source: O’Brien 2010 np link).

But not before the Yes Men had the final word in crafting an Apple-like response that only served to inform the public further about their issues (Source: Chansanchai 2010 np link).

After all of their pranks of the past, a press release from the actual company they targeted hits the news wires explaining that it was a prank, it wasn’t us, blah blah blah. Knowing this, the Yes Men released their own press release acting as Apple, explaining that it was a prank, it wasn’t us, blah blah blah (Source: Kelchner 2010 np link).

Yes Men crafted a clever mea culpa from Apple in its mock press release from a seemingly non-existent Apple spokesperson with a non-working number (Source: Chansanchai 2010 np link).

Apple wishes to inform the public that the so-called ‘conflict-free’ iPhone, promoted today outside the Apple Store at Fifth Avenue in New York City, featured on the non-Apple website www.apple-CF.com, and noted in a spoofed media advisory to numerous New York City reporters, is fraudulent and fictitious, and entirely the imagination of the group of pranksters who created it. To be perfectly clear, this product does not exist, and Apple has no connection to the group that promoted it. Furthermore, although Apple does have plans to certify its materials as conflict-free, this will by no means be any sort of solution to the situation of conflict in the Congo, nor in any way help bring an end to that conflict. Rather, the solution must be based in diplomacy. In this regard, there is a law on the books – the ‘Democratic Republic of the Congo Relief, Security, and Democracy Promotion Act,’ Public Law 109-456, introduced by then-Senator Obama in 2005 – that demands, among other things, the appointment of a special envoy to the Great Lakes region. As of now, four years later, this has still not happened, and the Congolese continue to die by the tens of thousands. There are various possible solutions to this problem, but it is up to you, not Apple, to accomplish them. Here are some things you can do: Report the violation of Public Law 109-456 to the FBI. Visit tips.fbi.gov to do so, or call 1-800-CALLFBI (225-5324). Culpable parties involve not only the President and the White House, but the Secretary of State, who is in charge of enforcing that portion of this law that demands the withholding of aid to destabilizing nations. You might consider performing a citizen’s arrest against the above parties. Any citizen can arrest someone committing a crime, if the crime is sufficiently grave. Millions of deaths in the Congo are, Apple believes, a very grave crime. You might also consider performing a citizen’s arrest against shareholders and officers of the mining companies that have been implicated in pillaging the resources of the Congo and fueling the conflict in the Congo over the past 14 years. Why not start with John Paulson, the majority shareholder of AngloGold Ashanti, the mining company most responsible for financially supporting rebel groups and furthering the Congo conflict. His office is located at 1251 Avenue Of The Americas (at 50th Street), Floor 50. We at Apple have acknowledged in the past that the conflict in the Congo, which has claimed many millions of lives, is fuelled in part by the provision of minerals that go into consumer electronic products, and not only Apple’s. However, so-called ‘conflict-free’ certification is not a real solution, merely a very tiny part of a real solution. Regardless of whether Apple or other companies produce ‘conflict-free’ products, the Congo conflict will not end until the U.S. government chooses to enforce its own laws (Source: Anon 2010b np link).

A Paulson spokesman did not immediately respond to a request for comment as to whether the Paulson office had been visited or called as a result of the campaign (Source: Delevigne 2010 np link).

By the end of the night … our message was effectively heard and seen by the general public as well as Apple (Source: Max 2016 np link).

Inspiration / process / technique / methodology

Recently, Apple has been the target of activist efforts increase awareness of conflict metal and press for corporations to renounce their use. Activists target market leaders because (1) that gets attention and (2) if market leaders change their behavior, others are likely to follow. The YesMen specialize in embarrassing corporations through fake public relations messages such as news releases and web sites (Source: Anon 2010a np link).

Made up of Andy Bichlbaum and Mike Bonanno (born Jacques Servin and Igor Vamos, respectively), the Yes Men operate by building fake PR websites for multi-national corporations and waiting for unsuspecting conference organizers or journalists to solicit speaking engagements via these sites (Source: Veldstra 2010 p.140).

The Yes Men’s work indicates an investment in this notion of humour and its liberatory or revolutionary potential. When the two describe their mission as one of changing the world, the Yes Men assume a moment of unveiling, a punchline that reveals the disjunction between the suffering of people ... and the massive profits and holdings of the multinational corporation[s] who never publicly claimed responsibility for that suffering (Source: Veldstra 2010 p.143).

We’re basically trying to change the world using creative techniques, trying to do something creative to make an impact in the media or in the world ... a prank seems like something you do for the hell of it ... a hoax is all about fooling people and what we do isn’t fooling people – it’s actually about informing them (Source: Bichlbaum in Lambert 2009 np link).

… ‘lying in order to tell the truth’ (Source: Bichlbaum in Anon 2011a np link).

In their joke, the Yes Men literally perform another way of being, another way of living as resistant and cheeky, within a system in which conformity is the easier (and often more applauded) choice. Ultimately, the Yes Men confront a bleak situation too common under neoliberal economic models: further loss to the disenfranchised, further profit to the enfranchised, and difficulty in corralling the energy and will to address the situation, and in response dress up, take on ridiculously punning pseudonyms and perform an alternative punch line, provoking maybe a laugh, perhaps a smile, or, at the very least, a glimmer of recognition not only of the problem, but on the level on which action occurs, in which the body can speak against cynical ideology (Source: Veldstra 2010 p.152).

Fake sites … are humorous parodies of commercial sites, and one that are created as a form of Internet Activism called cyber-activism. When considerable work is done, these may look like the real thing and can easily fool you (Source: Cross 2013 p.182).

The [iPhone 4cf] website … mimics the design and commercial language of the market-leading smartphone company Apple but reveals problems in the production of electronics through ‘identity correction’: creating a spoof website that shows what they think a corporation could and should be doing (Source: Kemppainen and Ylä-Anttila 2016 p.10 link).

Emulating The Yes Men is easier said than done. It all began when Andy Bichlbaum, one of the leading members of The Yes Men … instructed a class at Parsons New School for Design in New York City called The Yes Lab. The Yes Lab was formed to conduct experiments – social or breaching experiments (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.1 link).

Ideas were thrown around in the group and eventually one emerged above the rest when one of the students came up with the idea to address the war in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (henceforth DRC). She described the pattern of rape, torture, forced displacement, and the illegal use of child soldiers. ... They could not speak for other people, but they were interested in formulating a critique that made their position visible. They wanted to identify the closest connection they had with the conflict (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.3-4 link).

[They] chose their favorite electronic company as the target of their critique – Apple. Believing that Apple should put pressure on its minerals suppliers, the group created a campaign purporting that Apple had actually done so (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.1 link).

They tried to connect their local situation with the global conflict. They did not just want to criticize multinational corporations, they wanted to discover which connection they had with the conflict. Therefore they would not only criticize the company and their use of conflict minerals but also integrate the consumer – including themselves – in their critique (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.6 link).

They saw The Yes Lab as a learning experience. It put tools and methodologies for political activism in their hands. As The Yes Men in training, they developed this action in order to highlight not only an international conflict – including the conspicuous consumption of a capitalist society and its global ramifications – but also the difficulties of acting politically (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.13 link).

Because of all that information the students developed a strategy to both promote the knowledge of what was going on in the DRC as well as publicly make an example of a company that was glibly exploiting the conflict for their corporate social responsibility campaigns. Their focus of critique was Apple’s effort to represent itself and its customers as especially socially responsible. Additionally they wanted to inform consumers that political problems could not only be solved by corporations or by consumer buying habits but by political means ... The students created a fake product ... that served as a vehicle for all the information that they had unearthed during their work ... Using the aesthetics and stylistics of Apple, their campaign was made to mirror the company and their consumers that they were subverting. They provide to the consumer, who more than likely wants to believe that consumer buying habits have a strong influence on the environment, a solution for the conflict: buy a new gadget (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.8 link).

The students then proceeded to build an entire marketing campaign for the iPhone 4CF, including a website, flyer, ersatz Apple employees, business cards, customers, a pre-release event, a media advisory, hotline, a press conference, and a press release ... On the iPhone 4CF website and in the press release – everything in Apple’s corporate design – the students not only gave facts about laws that are being entirely ignored by the government but called for Situationist-inspired activism such as citizen’s arrest for pertinent abettors wrapped up in the conflict mineral trade and in not enforcing existing laws. For example, they called for the arrest of President Barack Obama, who does not enforce the 2005 law that he himself introduced while in the Senate: ‘Democratic Republic of the Congo Relief, Security, and Democracy Promotion Act.’ They also demanded the arrest of the hedge fund manager John Paulson, whose company finances some of the worst extraction practices (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.8 link).

... the Yes Men frequently play both sides of the corporate vs. activist game, first acting as the corporation itself in making an announcement, posing as the company, and then posing again as the ‘real’ company denying that the previous action was authentic … The power of the Yes Men campaign comes from this mind-bending juxtaposition, and the way that experiencing these two announcements draws the user into consciousness about the modes of production without ever using the term or even mentioning capitalism (Source: Oman-Reagan 2010 np link).

In the follow the things genre, experiments in ‘critical making’ have generated powerful critiques of, with and alternative to the injustices of ‘free market’ capitalism. The iPhone 4cf (2010), for example, is a ‘conflict free’ smartphone advertised on a spoof website - www.apple-cf.com - where consumers were encouraged to download, print out and take to their local Apple store a form that would allow them upgrade their iPhone to a non-existent ‘cf’ version without charge (Parkin 2011, np). Phone Story (2011) is a smartphone game in which, to get through one level for example, ‘while the narrator explains that most electronic devices require the mining of coltan, a conflict mineral in Congo whose demand spurs war and child labour, the player must use the touch screen to guide armed soldiers to bark at exhausted child miners in order to meet the goal in time’ (Alexander in Kemppainen et al 2012, np). And the ‘real’ Fairphone (2013) has been made and marketed to ‘create a fairer smartphone economy by building a phone’ whose ‘raw materials come from conflict-free mines, … [whose] manufacturers are paid a living wage, and … [whose] open source operating system … anyone can modify’ (Salek 2013, np). In each case, the critical making process used ‘the very device that [each] is criticizing as the vehicle for its criticism’ (O’Dwyer in Kemppainen et al 2012, np) (Source: Cook et al 2014 p.12 link).

Discussion / Responses

One thing Apple doesn't seem to suffer well: imitators, even those with do-gooder intentions, and especially those with a bone to pick about Apple buying minerals from countries that use those funds for wars (Source: Chansanchai 2010 np link).

When the Yes Men step out of character ... they come across as thin-skinned, distinctly unfunny ideologies who see all private enterprise as inherently corrupt. You can see this in their slickly produced knockoff of an Apple website that advertises the new iPhone 4CF (Source: Torrenzano and Davis 2011, p.89 link).

These guys deserve a Nobel Peace Prize for their tireless, breathtaking and hilarious work in all areas of activism (Source: grippinglyauthentic 2010 np link).

I love the Yes Men! Another stunning example of brilliance and a a (sic) real-life drama that leaves me on the edge of my seat with a surprising and disturbing degree of humor given the catastrophic situation at hand (Source: hypoluddite 2010 np link).

The website was taken down, but its existence and takedown generated a great deal of discussion about why Apple and other electronics companies weren’t producing phones like this, and how they could and should (Source: Kemppainen and Ylä-Anttila 2016 p.10 link).

Reading through the iPhone prank site, it becomes evident that its ultimate goal is not to take a bite out of Apple. As the Yes Men's fake press release notes, ‘although Apple does have plans to certify its materials as conflict-free, this will by no means be any sort of solution to the situation of conflict in the Congo, nor in any way help bring an end to that conflict. Rather, the solution must be based in diplomacy.’ That's a reasonable argument, and the Yes Men deserve credit for not repeating the simplistic view that we, the American consumer, can bring peace to the DRC by merely boycotting blood tantalum or buying the right kind of electronics (Source: Gilson 2010 np link).

Essentially, the [iPhone 4CF] prank was to raise general awareness of conflict minerals and their usage in the electronic industry. It wasn’t a direct attack on Apple, but I would guess they performed it at Apple since it is one of the most popular electronic manufactures in the world. The real act of their mischief was with the press release where they explained this is much bigger than Apple, and even bigger than corporations (Source: Kelchner 2010 np link).

While their intentions may be genuine, the Yes Men need to do more fact-checking before they spout off. Dave Gilson from Mother Jones makes some corrections in the content of the campaign that show the complexities of the Congolese situation and that the specific companies the Yes Men blame may not be the most effective in curtailing the violence, which is the ultimate goal of the activists (Source: Chansanchai 2010 np link).

... while the Yes Men's design and humor are spot-on, making them phenomenal pranksters, their politics are a bit simplistic, making them less than ideal activists. Mother Jones is no bosom buddy to multinational corporations, but [Mother Jones writer] Gilson ... points out that conflict minerals simply don't appear to be the root of the DRC's problem. It's ‘a conflict complicated by dozens of major players and a web of regional politics and rivalries,’ he writes, and, noting that the Yes Men plan to re-launch their site, adds: ‘Here's hoping the Yes Men work out some of these glitches before they roll out the 2.0 version of the iPhone 4cf’ (Source: Zax 2010 np link).

The Yes Men have come under intense criticism for their simplistic politics which render them less than ideal activists; their campaigns no more than impressive graphic designs and publicity grabbing stunts. Is this the only way to harvest a good crop of responsible Apple products? Or is there a more constructive NGO approach to identify what rots the core of the Apple giant? And how is Apple reacting to those NGOs whose campaigns constantly afflict the Apple brand (Source: iphoneproj2011 2011 np link)?

I still do not like witch hunts, so I'm not thrilled with this kind of smear campaign. But if we were indeed able to think about the global and permanent consequences of all our choices, including the most futile (but not necessarily the ones with the least impact), it would not be bad. No (Source: Bosman 2010 np link)?

Beside the reaction from Apple itself, the students received attention from the public, the police, as well as the press. The fact that critics viewed the action as irritating could be considered proof that the actual purpose of the breaching experiment/performance had been achieved (Source: Mönkedieck 2011 p.2 link).

Are we suggesting that you give up your iPhone or any of the other gadgets that contain conflict minerals? No. We are, after all, users of this technology ourselves - at least until we figure out how to transmit our weblog directly to your minds. We are simply passing on information that isn’t exactly at the forefront of everyone’s attention. As Nicholas D. Kristof says in his Op-Ed piece: ‘It’s not that American tech companies are responsible for the slaughter, or that eliminating conflict minerals from Americans’ phones will immediately end the war. Even the Enough Project, an anti-genocide organization that has been a leading force in the current campaign, estimates that only one-fifth of the world’s tantalum comes from Congo.’ But awareness is a step toward solution. There simply has to be a better way. We should all know where the products that are a part of our everyday lives come from, what the impact is, and what it means to our future and our past (Source: grippinglyauthentic 2010 np link).

After the threat from Apple to completely remove the upstream provider of the [iPhone 4CF] site, the content was removed by the hoster. [Such] speed and consistency … would be welcome in the fight against the use of ‘blood minerals’, but [is] completely lacking there. Obviously, it's more important to the company to preserve their supposedly clean image without advocating fair and equitable delivery and delivery of the necessary product components. So far, the Yes Men have not been able to find another host for the site (Source: Anon 2011b np link).

Too bad that the iPhone 4CF was not genuine (Source: Bjoern 2014 np link).

Outcomes / Impacts

‘None of us can build a complete computer, we depend on the industry,’ … [says Sebastian] Jekutsch [from the Forum Computer Scientists for Peace and Social Responsibility]. The brand manufacturers would therefore have to take action. This is possible in principle, but not easy to achieve. The computer scientist listed a ‘primeval soup’ of activities that could put pressure on well-known companies. This begins with actions and protests, such as the activist group ‘Yes Men’ with their announcement of a conflict-free ‘iPhone 4CF’ had previously worked out. Also important are legal framework conditions, the constant inquiries with the dealer, the creation of uniform seals and certificates and the publishing of rankings of fair manufacturers, as it operates Greenpeace for green electronics. According to Jekutsch, campaigns for fair IT are run by several initiatives such as Enough, Germanwatch, GoodElectronics and Weed. Their employees also researched locally and took care of lobby work (Source: Krempl 2012 np link).

In an e-mail to [Apple CEO Steve] Jobs on Sunday evening, Wired.com reader Derick Rhodes inquired about whether Apple was using ‘conflict-free’ materials to create the iPhone 4. Jobs shot back a reply an hour later stating that Apple was doing what it could[:] Hi Steve, I’d planned to buy a new iPhone tomorrow – my first upgrade since buying the very first version on the first day of its release – but I’m hesitant without knowing Apple’s position on sourcing the minerals in its products. Are you currently making any effort to source conflict-free minerals? In particular, I’m concerned that Apple is getting tantalum, tungsten, tin, and gold from Eastern Congo through its suppliers. Looking forward to your response, Derick. ... Jobs’ reply: Yes. We require all of our suppliers to certify in writing that they use conflict few materials. But honestly there is no way for them to be sure. Until someone invents a way to chemically trace minerals from the source mine, it’s a very difficult problem. Rhodes was inspired to write the e-mail after reading a recent New York Times piece detailing the horrific warfare in the Congo, which sells minerals to the suppliers who create components for cellphones, computers and gaming devices. Grass-roots campaigns have dubbed minerals from such origins as ‘conflict minerals’ (Source: Chen 2010 np link).

What are the steps to a conflict-free iPhone? [Friends of the Congo’s Kambale Musavuni]: Ultimately, ending the conflict in the Congo is a step towards a conflict-free iPhone. As a global community, we can play a constructive role by supporting, for example, courageous Congolese and local groups who work to end the conflict and thus bring about sustainable change. We can convince our politicians that they are putting pressure on the Congo's neighboring countries, which have destabilized the country through invasions, support for armed groups and exploitation of minerals. We should also put pressure on the mining companies (Source: Musavuli in Musavuli & Bonanno nd np link).

[The iPhone 4CF] soon moved from a prank to reality as companies such as Intel started integrating this into their supply chains and marking products as CF (Source: Bansal & Jain 2017 np link).

Researchers and product innovators have been developing the idea of a conflict free smartphone from an activist stunt (the iPhone 4cf) into a real product (the Fairphone) (Source: Kemppainen and Ylä-Anttila 2016 p.11 link).

Sources / Further Reading

Anon (2010a) Fwd: Alert: fraudulent conflict-free iPhone hoax originating from Apple address. spectregroup.wordpress.com 17th November (http://spectregroup.wordpress.com/2010/11/17/fwd-alert-fraudulent-conflict-free-iphone-hoax-originating-from-apple-address/ last accessed 27th June 2017)

Anon (2010b) Apple + Conflict Metals = Trouble with Activists. prstrategyandapplication.wordpress.com 30th November (http://prstrategyandapplication.wordpress.com/2010/11/30/apple-conflict-metals-trouble-with-activists/ last accessed 27th June 2017)

Anon (2011a) Modern Day Clark Kents: Engaging Your Modern Superhero. tmuny.org (http://tmuny.org/connect/blog/modern-day-clark-kents-engaging-your-inner-superhero last accessed 30 June 2011)

Anon (2011b) Kingo: fluch der bodenschätze. Travelbeyond.de 10th January (http://www.travelbeyond.de/nc/news/aktuelles/news-detailansicht/archiv/2011/01/article/kongo-fluch-der-bodenschaetze.html last accessed 16th January 2018, via Google Translate)

Aust, D. (2010) Angriff der Guerillas: Apple Der Ja Männer haben eine neue gefälschte Homepage. Die Tagezeitung  20 November [translated into English by Nexis.com]

Bansal, N. & Jain, S. (2017) The last lesson: a general quiz Gnosis MNNIT Quiz Club 15th April (https://www.slideshare.net/NitinBansal24/general-quiz-75042655 last accessed 28th June 2017)

Bjoern (2014) Nicht (nur) grün, sondern fair – gibt es fair-it? Greencomputingportal.de 25th November (http://www.greencomputingportal.de/artikel/nicht-nur-gruen-sondern-fair-gibt-es-fair/ last accessed 16th January 2018, via Google Translate)

Bosman, D. (2010) iPhone 4CF. davidbosman.fr 28th November (https://davidbosman.fr/blog/2010/11/18/iphone-4cf/ last accessed 16th January 2018, via Google Translate)

Chansanchai, A. (2010) Apple says no to Yes Men’s fake iPhone site. technolog.msnbc.msn.com 22nd November (http://technolog.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2010/11/22/5509098-apple-says-no-to-yes-mens-fake-iphone-site last accessed 30th June 2011)

Chen, B. (2010) In e-mail, Steve Jobs comments on iPhone 4 Minerals. wired.com 28th June (www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2010/06/steve-jobs-iphone4/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+wired%2Find last accessed 27th June 2017)

Cook et al , I. (2014) Fabrication critique et web 2.0: les géographies matérielles de followthethings.com. Géographie et cultures91-92, 23-48 (English translation https://ore.exeter.ac.uk/repository/bitstream/handle/10871/21880/Cook%20et%20al%20Critical%20Making%20paper%20for%20GeC%20.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y last accessed 16 January 2018)

Cross, M. (2013) Social Media Security: Leveraging Social Networking While Mitigating Risk, Newnes: Oxford/Boston

Delevigne, L. (2010)  ‘Yes Men’ pranksters call for citizen’s arrest of John Paulson. Absolute return + alpha 17 November (www.absolutereturn-alpha.com/Article/2717294/Yes-Men-pranksters-call-for-citizens-arrest-of-John-Paulson.html last accessed 6th July 2010)

Gilson, D. (2010) The Yes Men hack the iPhone. Mother Jones 19th November (http://motherjones.com/mojo/2010/11/yes-men-iphone-congo last accessed 27th June 2017)

grippinglyauthentic (2010) This changes everything. Agai. grippinglyauthentic.com 18th November (http://grippinglyauthentic.com/2010/11/18/this-changes-everything-again/ last accessed 30th June 2010)

hypoluddite (2010) iPhone 4cf: conflict free iPhone. religionandtechnology.com 17th November (http://religionandtechnology.com/2010/11/16/iphone-4cf-conflict-free-iphone/ last accessed 30th June 2011)

iphoneproj2011 (2011) The new iPhone 4 cf: just an ideal? iphoneproj2011.wordpress.com 19th April (http://iphoneproj2011.wordpress.com/2011/04/19/the-new-iphone-4-cf-just-an-ideal/ last accessed 27th June 2017)

Kelchner, A. (2010) Conflict minerals of Congo. The world wide web of society 12th November (http://internetculture.wordpress.com/2010/12/09/conflict-minerals-congo/ last accessed 6th July 2011)

Kemppainen, E. & Ylä-Anttila, A. (2016) Teaching media literacy & geographies of consumption, Eeva Kemppainen & Pro Ethical Trade Finland, Helsinki (http://www.eetti.fi/sites/default/files/Subvertisement_Workshop.pdf last accessed 16 January 2018)

Krempl, S. (2012) 29C3: Auf der Suche nach dem ‘fairen’ Computer. Heise Online 30th December (https://www.heise.de/newsticker/meldung/29C3-Auf-der-Suche-nach-dem-fairen-Computer-1775096.html last accessed 16 January 2018, via Google Translate)

Lambert, S. (2009) The Yes Men. Bomb Magazine 107 (http://bombsite.com/issues/107/articles/3263 last accessed 27th June 2017)

Max (2016) The Yes Men ‘Yes Lab’: Apple iPhone 4CF Action (2011), CargoCollective (https://cargocollective.com/maxmgardner/Strategic-Creative-Advertising last accessed 28th June 2017)

maxmgard (2015) comment on Andrew Lapin’s article The Yes Are Revolting, The Dissolve, 2015 (https://thedissolve.com/reviews/1640-the-yes-men-are-revolting/ last accessed 28th June 2017)

Mönkedieck , S. (2011) The iPhone 4CF (Conflict Free): the Yes Men address the conflict in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. Liminalities 7(4), December ( http://liminalities.net/7-4/yesmen.pdf last accessed 27th June 2017)

Musavuli, K. & Bonanno, M. (nd) Das erste konfliktfreie iPhone von Apple – die Geschichte einer Falschmeldung.  germanwatch.org (https://germanwatch.org/3991 last accessed 16th January 2018, via Google Translate)

O’Brien, T. (2010) Yes Men protest conflict minerals with iPhone 4cf, Apple slaps back. switched.com 22nd November (www.switched.com/2010/11/22/yes-men-iphone-4cf-apple-slaps-back-conflict-minerals/ last accessed 30th June 2010)

Oman-Reagan, M. (2010) iPhone 4cf: conflict free iPhone. religionandtechnology.com 16th November (http://religionandtechnology.com/2010/11/16/iphone-4cf-conflict-free-iphone/ last accessed 27th June 2017)

Smith, J. & Mantz, J. (2006) Do cellular phones dream of civil war? the mystification of production and the consequences of technology fetishism in the Eastern Congo. in Kirsch, M. (ed) Inclusion and exclusion in the global arena. New York: Routledge. (http://mason.gmu.edu/%7Ejmantz/Coltan.pdf last accessed 23rd June 2011)

Torrenzano, R. & Davis, M. (2011) Digital assassination: protecting your reputation, brand, or business against online attacks. New York: St Martin’s Press

Veldstra, C. (2010) Patron saint of lost causes, live on the BBC: the Yes Men, humour and the possibility of politics. Nordic Journal of English Studies 9(3), p.138-153

Yes Men (2010) What more can we do. apple-cf.com.yeslab.org (http://apple-cf.com.yeslab.org/what last accessed 16th January 2018)

YesLab (2010) Apple goes ‘Conflict Free’. yeslab.org 18 November (http://yeslab.org/project/iphonecf last accessed 16 January 2018)

Zax, D. (2010) Yes Men attack apple, advertising special ‘conflict free’ iPhone. fastcompany.com, 19th November (http://www.fastcompany.com/1703966/yes-men-attack-apple-advertising-special-conflict-free-iphone last accessed 27th June 2017)

Photo credit

webdesignhot.com (nd) Vector iPhone 4. webdesignhot.com (www.webdesignhot.com/free-vector-graphics/vector-iphone-4/ last accessed 6 July 2011)

Slideshow credit

religionandtechnology.com (2010) iPhone 4cf: conflict free iPhone. flickr creative commons 16 November (www.flickr.com/photos/escapehelicopter/sets/72157625282975715/with/5183642556/ last accessed 6 July 2011)

Compiled by Jack Parkin andedited by Caroline Weston Goodman as part of followthethings.com internships, and edited by Ian Cook (last updated January 2018). iPhone 4CF website screenshots reproduced under Creative Commons license. This page is also available in Finnish, here. Translation supported by the Kone Foundation.